Russian Federation
UDC 614.8
The article provides a brief review and criteria-based analysis of studies dedicated to the problem of optimal/rational placement of emergency rescue units. Key approaches to solving this problem are considered, including mathematical optimization methods, geoinformation technologies, and simulation modeling. An analysis of relevant works was conducted based on fourteen criteria, which were the following characteristics: objective, subject area, problem being solved, solution methods, model used, input data, output data, tools applied, implementation degree, calculated metrics, optimality criteria, objective function, development prospects, limitations, and assumptions. These criteria will help to draw more precise and specific conclusions for the modernization of the stated problem of optimal/rational emergency rescue units placement.
optimal placement, emergency rescue units, criteria-based analysis, mathematical and simulation modeling, geographic information systems, multi-criteria analysis methods, artificial intelligence methods
1. Problemno-orientirovannye imitacionnye sistemy dlya avtomatizirovannogo proektirovaniya i strategicheskogo upravleniya ekstrennymi i avarijno-spasatel'nymi sluzhbami gorodov / E.M. Alekhin [i dr.] // Vestnik RAEN. 2012. T. 12. № 3. S. 27–34. EDN: https://elibrary.ru/TXIKGX.
2. Aparin A.A. Opredelenie predpochtitel'nyh territorij pozharno-spasatel'nogo garnizona pri planirovanii razmeshcheniya sistem videomonitoringa // «Bezopasnost' i ohrana truda» (BIOT-2022): sb. trudov konkursa NIR. Moskva, 2022. S. 6–9. EDN: https://elibrary.ru/TUSTDM.
3. Biryukov D.S., Zaslavskaya O.V. Optimal'noe razmeshchenie i komplektaciya avarijno-spasatel'nyh sluzhb dlya reagirovaniya na chrezvychajnye situacii // Vestnik Nacional'nogo tekhnicheskogo universiteta Har'kovskij politekhnicheskij institut. 2013. № 39 (1012). S. 3–8. EDN RCNMPZ.
4. Gusev S.A. Optimal'noe raspolozhenie spasatel'nyh sluzhb // Transportnoe delo Rossii. 2017. № 6. S. 72–79. EDN: https://elibrary.ru/YMTHWJ.
5. Tekhnologii matematicheskogo modelirovaniya dlya opredeleniya optimal'nyh mest dislokacii specializirovannyh pozharno-spasatel'nyh chastej / V.V. Harin [i dr.] // Monitoring, modelirovanie i prognozirovanie opasnyh prirodnyh yavlenij i chrezvychajnyh situacij: sb. materialov Mezhdunar. nauch.-prakt. konf. Krasnoyarsk, 2022. S. 12–18. EDN: https://elibrary.ru/FXHTPE.
6. Matyushev P.A., Zaripova S.N. O modelirovanii optimal'nogo razmeshcheniya avarijno-spasatel'nyh formirovanij na territorii sub"ekta Rossijskoj Federacii // Modelirovanie slozhnyh processov i sistem: sb. trudov sekcii № 12 XXXI Mezhdunar. nauch.-prakt. konf. Himki, 2021. S. 5–16. EDN: https://elibrary.ru/MBZYVE.
7. Obosnovanie racional'nyh mest razmeshcheniya avarijno-spasatel'nyh sil na osnove risk-orientirovannyh podhodov / R.A. Durnev [i dr.] // Problemy analiza riska. 2025. T. 22. № 2. S. 58–65. EDN CCFUXS.
8. Analysis of the location of rescue ambulance dispatch bases: a case study in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil / T. Ferrari [et al.] // Geographical Analysis. 2018. Vol. 50. № 4. P. 397–421.
9. Akbari A., Eiselt H.A., Pelot R.A. Maritime search and rescue location analysis considering multiple criteria, with simulated demand // INFOR: Information Systems and Operational Research. 2018. Vol. 56. №. 1. P. 92–114.
10. Dahlgren A., Harrie L., Axelsson A. Planning rescue services with non-stationary rescue units // Fire technology. 2009. Vol. 45. P. 239–255.
11. Chen L., Miller-Hooks E. Optimal team deployment in urban search and rescue // Transportation Research Part B: Methodological. 2012. Vol. 46. № 8. P. 984–999.
12. A Multi-Objective Decision Model of Traffic Rescue Service Site Location on Road / G. Chai [et al.] // ICCTP 2009: Critical Issues in Transportation Systems Planning, Development, and Management. 2009. P. 1–7.
13. Cheng Yu.H., Liang Z.X. A strategic planning model for the railway system accident rescue problem // Transportation research part E: logistics and transportation review. 2014. Vol. 69. P. 75–96.
14. Clarke A., Miles J.C. Strategic Fire and Rescue Service decision making using evolutionary algorithms // Advances in Engineering Software. 2012. Vol. 50. P. 29–36.
15. Liu M., Yang D., Hao F. Optimization for the Locations of Ambulances under Two‐Stage Life Rescue in the Emergency Medical Service: A Case Study in Shanghai, China // Mathematical Problems in Engineering. 2017. № 1. P. 1830480.
16. Research on the location model of emergency rescue facilities in the city disaster prevention / Q.Z. Sun [et al.] // Applied Mechanics and Materials. 2015. Vol. 744. P. 1745–1748.
17. Andersson T., Särdqvist S. Planning for effective use of fire and rescue service resources // Interflam 2007: 11th International Fire Science & Engineering Conference, London, 2007. P. 1561–1566.
18. Pelot R., Akbari A., Li L. Vessel location modeling for maritime search and rescue // Applications of location analysis. 2015. P. 369–402.
19. Dey A., Heger A., England D. Urban fire station location planning using predicted demand and service quality index // International Journal of Data Science and Analytics. 2023. Vol. 15. № 1. P. 33–48.
20. A new partial coverage locating model for cooperative fire services / J. Wang [et al.] // Information Sciences. 2016. Vol. 373. P. 527–538.
21. Ahunova D.G., Bujnevich M.V., Vlasov S.S. Obespechenie pozharnoj bezopasnosti proizvodstvennyh ob"ektov na osnove informatizacii risk-menedzhmentnogo podhoda // Prirodnye i tekhnogennye riski (fiziko-matematicheskie i prikladnye aspekty). 2020. № 1 (33). S. 4–11.
22. Bujnevich M.V., Ahunova D.G., Yaroshenko A.Yu. Kompleksnyj metod resheniya tipovoj zadachi risk-menedzhmenta v infologicheskoj srede (na primere ranzhirovaniya trebovanij pozharnoj bezopasnosti). Chast' 1 // Nauch.-analit. zhurn. «Vestnik S.-Peterb. un-ta GPS MCHS Rossii». 2020. № 3. S. 88–99.
23. Bujnevich M.V., Ahunova D.G., Yaroshenko A.Yu. Kompleksnyj metod resheniya tipovoj zadachi risk-menedzhmenta v infologicheskoj srede (na primere ranzhirovaniya trebovanij pozharnoj bezopasnosti). Chast' 2 // Nauch.-analit. zhurn. «Vestnik S.-Peterb. un-ta GPS MCHS Rossii». 2020. № 4. S. 78–89.
24. Ahunova D.G. Imitacionnaya model' podderzhki prinyatiya reshenij po razmeshcheniyu pozharno-spasatel'nyh podrazdelenij na territorii Sankt-Peterburga // Nauch.-analit. zhurn. «Vestnik S.-Peterb. un-ta GPS MCHS Rossii». 2023. № 3. S. 152–163.
25. Bujnevich M.V., Pelekh M.T., Ahunova D.G. Razvitie pozharnoj ohrany megapolisa s ispol'zovaniem tekhnologii imitacionnogo modelirovaniya // Nauch.-analit. zhurn. «Vestnik S.-Peterb. un-ta GPS MCHS Rossii». 2019. № 3. S. 150–156.
26. Bujnevich M.V., Shurakova D.G., Vostryh A.V. Dvuhurovnevaya klasterizaciya suboptimal'nyh zon prikrytiya g. Kostromy podrazdeleniyami MCHS Rossii pri vozniknovenii proisshestvij // Nauch.-analit. zhurn. «Vestnik S.-Peterb. un-ta GPS MCHS Rossii». 2018. № 2. S. 121–127.
27. Izrailov K.E. Primenenie geneticheskih algoritmov dlya dekompilyacii mashinnogo koda // Zashchita informacii. Insajd. 2020. № 3 (93). S. 24–30.
28. Ahunova D.G., Matveev A.V. O nauchno-metodicheskom obespechenii lokacii avarijno-spasatel'nyh sluzhb v Arkticheskoj zone rossijskoj federacii // Tekhnosfernaya bezopasnost' v Arktike: sb. materialov VIII Mezhdunar. nauch.-prakt. konf. Sankt-Peterburg, 2025. S. 11–15.
29. Ahunova D.G., Vostryh A.V., Kurta P.A. Ocenka pol'zovatel'skogo interfejsa informacionnyh sistem posredstvam modelej kachestva programmnogo obespecheniya // Informatizaciya i svyaz'. 2020. № 2. S. 127–135.
30. Ahunova D.G. Programmnyj modul' opredeleniya optimal'nyh marshrutov dostavki sil i sredstv v zonu proisshestvij na territorii Sankt-Peterburga // Prirodnye i tekhnogennye riski (fiziko-matematicheskie i prikladnye aspekty). 2023. № 3 (47). S. 36–43.
31. Ahunova D.G., Vostryh A.V. Preimushchestva perekhoda na celeorintirovannoe proektirovanie interfejsov dlya mobil'nyh pol'zovatelej informacionnyh sistem // Modernizaciya informacionnoj infrastruktury dlya setej 5G/IMT 2020 i dlya drugih perspektivnyh tekhnologij v interesah transformacii regionov ROSINFOKOM-2019: sb. nauch. statej. Sankt-Peterburg, 2019. S. 5–9.
32. Vostryh A.V., Shurakova D.G. Komponenty special'noj informacionnoj tekhnologii postroeniya optimal'nyh marshrutov // Aktual'nye problemy infotelekommunikacij v nauke i obrazovanii: sb. trudov VII Mezhdunar. nauch.-tekhn. i nauch.-metod. konf. Sankt-Peterburg, 2018. S. 213–218.
